I'm writing my own mesh renderer, and I previously was able to apply a normal map to a sphere, so I understand the basic process of applying a normal map. But my understanding is that in order to apply it, you need a consistent tangent space at every point on the mesh. It's possible on a sphere because you can calculate the spherical coordinates and then pick orthogonal tangents parallel to lines of longitude/latitude, but as far as I can tell, there's no clear way to do that to a mesh.

To give a specific example, I found this free .obj file online, and I can render it with textures, just without normal mapping. But I can open up the model in the generic Windows "3D Viewer", and in that program, it has normal mapping applied, so clearly it's possible. I couldn't find anything online, is there a way to do this?


There are numerous approaches to setting up tangent bases on a mesh, and unfortunately, no totally universal standard for how they are calculated.

Tangents are based on the mesh's UV mapping, so that the tangent vector points (at least roughly) along the U axis in texture space, and the bitangent along the V axis. This means each triangle in a mesh has its own tangent basis (as long as the UV mapping is nondegenerate). This often gets converted into a smoothed tangent basis per vertex, much like you can create smoothed normals by setting each vertex normal to an average over the normals of the surrounding triangles. Different tools and engines might do the smoothing in different ways, might handle UV seams and mirroring differently, might orthonormalize the basis per vertex or per pixel or not at all, etc. Here is a nice article to read if you want to know more. And as noted there, there is a method for tangent spaces called mikktspace that is gradually gaining widespread support and might become a de facto standard.

Object/character models like the one you linked usually have normal maps baked out from a content creation tool (e.g. based on an ultra-high-detail source mesh); ideally, you need the tangent basis you use in your renderer to match the tangent basis used in the tool to do the bake. Sometimes there will be vertex tangents stored in the mesh, but the .obj format doesn't support tangents so you would need to see if the model has tangents in one of the other formats, like .fbx.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.